9.03.2005

My empathy is not fuel for your agenda

I just received this comment to my below post within 5 minutes of posting it.

"Typical liberal response....symbolism ovr substance....

Why don't you send an abortionist down there and kill off all of those un-wanted black babies....

You are an idiot."

--
Posted by The Shadow to Quilt Art Quests and Quandries... at 9/03/2005 09:21:18 AM

Sigh.

There is an ENORMOUS difference between 'unwanted' and 'bad timing.'

If folks WANT to conceive during all of this, well then, power to them! I can see where such a wonderful blessing at this point would be very calming, and would convey a sense that life will go on, no matter what the devastation.

I can also see where it might be a headache some folks would rather avoid just now. I'm thinking about the folks who normally use birth control, and whom Katrina has taken it away from. They deserve to be able to make their choice too.

And none of this is even looking at STDs - lots of people are looking for whatever comfort they can find right now, and they shouldn't have to risk getting some horrible disease to get it.

And before anyone says that I am saying that 'poor black people have no self-control and are rutting like bunnies' - these people have been through hell, and anything that brings them some peace is a good thing, as long as it isn't hurting anyone. I would prefer if it didn't risk them getting hurt in the process - they don't deserve more pain.

___

I also feel for the person who felt that they needed to lambast me. Whatever they have dealt with that makes them assume that I am 'one of *those* people' is a travesty.

That said, it would be really nice if people would actually look at the intent behind a posting before deciding that it vallidates their own personal agendas - whether they agree or disagree with me. I am an independant thinker, and I rarely jump on *any* bandwagon; I am much more likely to discover that my own little soapbox fits in nicely with someone else's and enjoy their commeraderie, but I try very hard never to allow their voice to become mine.

If you don't like something that I have to say, please call me an idiot, but please do not insult me by saying that I have 'a typical liberal response.' Most of my views *are* very liberal, but they are, first and foremost, MY views, and not those spoonfed to me by some platform or other.

Also? Have the decency to leave an actual address to reply to - throwing statements out without making *any* provision for dialog is highly unlikely to ever solve anything.

2 comments:

  1. The response was over the top juvenile. But yesterday I was reading a Houston blog by 2 women attorneys who have been volunteering at the Astrodome and the Convention Ctr. and condoms as well as other hygience and medicinal products, where being asked for donations due to seeing refugees w/ HIV/AIDS and so many open wounds on people in general. I also wondered how people with drug addictions where coping.

    ReplyDelete
  2. You tell 'em! I thought your posting made a lot of sense and before anyone can say anything, let me preface it by saying that I'm Black. It's amazing the things you don't think about needing until you have no access to them whatsoever. I heard that things such as basic hygiene items like tampons, underwear, etc. were some of the things needed the most.

    ReplyDelete